Skip to content
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
CATERING DELIVERY: $30 Local Delivery / $50 >10 km
How to Choose the Perfect Cake for Every Occasion How to Choose the Perfect Cake for Every Occasion
  • Blog
  • How to Choose the Perfect Cake for Every Occasion

How to Choose the Perfect Cake for Every Occasion

Cakes are more than just desserts; they are the centrepiece of celebrations, the sweet exclamation point to moments of joy. Whether it’s a birthday, wedding, or casual get-together, the right cake can elevate the event. But how do you choose the perfect cake for each occasion? Here’s a guide to help you navigate the world of flavours, designs, and occasions, ensuring your cake is always a hit.

Understand the Occasion

The first step in choosing the perfect cake is understanding the event's significance. Different occasions call for varying levels of formality, flavours, and designs.

1. Weddings

A wedding cake is often the star of the dessert table. Choose something elegant, often with multiple tiers, adorned with decorations that complement the wedding theme. Popular flavours include classic options like vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet, but don’t shy away from modern choices like salted caramel or lemon raspberry.

2. Birthdays

For birthdays, the cake should reflect the personality of the guest of honour. Kids might love colourful cakes with fun themes (superheroes, princesses, or dinosaurs), while adults might prefer sophisticated flavours like tiramisu or a decadent chocolate truffle cake.

3. Anniversaries

Romantic and classic flavours like strawberry, chocolate, or champagne cakes are ideal for anniversaries. A simple yet elegant design, often decorated with flowers or a monogram, works well for such intimate celebrations.

4. Graduations

Graduation cakes can be more playful, with designs featuring the graduate's school colours, caps, or even mini diplomas. A flavour that pleases the crowd, such as chocolate fudge or vanilla, is always a safe bet.

5. Casual Get-togethers

For smaller or casual gatherings, the cake doesn’t need to be extravagant. A simple single-tier cake or even cupcakes with flavours like lemon, carrot, or marble cake can be perfect for such informal occasions.

Choose the Right Flavor

1. Chocolate

Rich, indulgent, and loved by many, chocolate is a go-to for birthdays, graduations, and even weddings. If you’re unsure, a chocolate cake will rarely disappoint.

2. Vanilla

A classic choice, vanilla cakes are versatile and can be paired with a variety of fillings and frostings. Great for both formal and casual events.

3. Red Velvet

A trendy choice for weddings, Valentine’s Day, or anniversary celebrations. Its rich flavour and vibrant red colour make it visually and tastefully appealing.

4. Lemon

Perfect for spring and summer events, lemon cake is light, zesty, and refreshing, ideal for baby showers or outdoor parties.

5. Fruit-Based Cakes

Flavors like strawberry, raspberry, or pineapple are great for summer gatherings, baby showers, and more light-hearted events where you want something sweet but not too heavy.

6. Specialty Flavors

Salted caramel, coffee, tiramisu, or spiced cakes work well for adult-centric parties, cocktail events, or dessert tables at weddings.

Consider Dietary Preferences

With an increasing number of dietary restrictions and preferences, it’s important to consider these when selecting your cake. Some things to keep in mind include:

Vegan

Whether for ethical reasons or dietary restrictions, vegan cakes are a great choice for occasions where plant-based eating is a priority. Options like chocolate or vanilla vegan cakes can be as rich and delicious as their non-vegan counterparts.

Gluten-Free

Gluten-free cakes cater to those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities. You can find excellent gluten-free options that don’t compromise on flavour or texture.

Sugar-Free or Low-Sugar

For occasions where health-conscious choices are important, such as baby showers or birthday parties for those watching their sugar intake, a low-sugar cake can be a thoughtful option.

Design & Decoration

The visual appeal of a cake is just as important as its taste. When choosing the design, think about how it will complement the event’s theme, decor, and mood.

Classic & Elegant

For formal occasions like weddings or anniversaries, opt for clean, elegant designs with minimal but sophisticated decorations. Think smooth fondant, cascading flowers, or intricate lacework.

Themed & Fun

Birthdays and kids’ parties call for more creativity. Consider playful designs featuring cartoon characters, sports themes, or favorite hobbies.

Modern & Trendy

For a contemporary twist, naked cakes, drip cakes, and geode cakes are all the rage. These designs are not only visually striking but also allow for customization to fit the event’s color scheme.

Serving Size & Tiers

The size of your cake should match the number of guests. A multi-tiered cake is perfect for large weddings or milestone birthday parties, while a smaller, single-tier cake works well for intimate gatherings.

Two-Tier Cakes

Great for mid-sized events like anniversaries or graduation parties.

Three or More Tiers

Best for weddings or events with large guest lists.

Cupcakes

Perfect for casual get-togethers or children's parties, where guests may prefer individual portions.

Final Touch: Personalization

Adding a personal touch to your cake makes it even more special. This could be:

  • A custom cake topper with the couple's initials or names for a wedding.
  • A playful message for a birthday.
  • Graduation caps, diplomas, or edible gold leaf for a celebratory flair.
The level of personalization should match the tone of the event, whether it’s lighthearted or formal.

Choosing the perfect cake for any occasion is an art that balances flavor, design, and personalization. Consider the significance of the event, cater to your guests' tastes, and match the design with the theme to make your cake the perfect complement to your celebration. Whether you go for a simple, classic cake or an extravagant, multi-tiered masterpiece, the right cake can turn any event into a memorable occasion.

Why Coniston Bakery is Your Go-To Cake Shop

When it comes to finding the perfect cake, Coniston Bakery is your one-stop destination for both off-the-shelf delights and custom-made masterpieces. With various flavours, styles, and dietary-friendly options, Coniston Bakery ensures that every occasion is catered to with care and creativity. Whether you're planning a last-minute gathering, need a delicious ready-made cake, or want to collaborate on a personalised design for a special event, Coniston Bakery offers high-quality craftsmanship and exceptional service. Let Coniston Bakery sweeten your celebrations with the perfect cake for every occasion!

Happy cake hunting - Start your custom cake shopping right here!

Discover More

View all
best cafe in wollongong
From Bakery to Café: Why Coniston Bakery is Wollongong’s New Favourite SpotFor years, locals have known Coniston Bakery as the go-to place for cakes, pastries, and baked goods that are second to none. People came from across the Illawarra to pick up a fresh loaf, a flaky croissant, or a custom cake for their celebrations. Our reputation has always been built on flavour, freshness, and quality — so much so that we were proudly voted the Best Bakery in the Illawarra region. But as more and more customers asked for a place to sit, relax, and enjoy their food with a coffee in hand, something new began to take shape. Today, Coniston Bakery isn’t just a bakery anymore. We’re on our way to becoming one of Wollongong’s premier cafés. More Than Cakes and Pastries When we first opened our doors, it was all about the cakes and pastries. Customers lined up for our flaky danishes, rich brownies, and indulgent slices. And while those treats are still at the heart of what we do, our menu has grown in exciting new directions. Now, our cafés serve up: Grilled meals for breakfast, brunch, and lunch. Gluten-free options so everyone can find something delicious. Decadent desserts and treats baked fresh daily. Coffee in every style — hot, cold, creamy, strong, and everything in between. Cold drinks and grab-and-go choices for those on a busy schedule. The result? A space where you can not only buy a cake for your next party, but also stay, sit down, and enjoy a meal with friends, family, or colleagues. Why Customers Keep Coming Back The transformation from bakery to café has been fuelled by our loyal customers. Once people step inside and experience the food and warm atmosphere, they come back again and again.  What makes the experience different? Friendly staff who remember your order and make you feel at home. Generous portions that leave you satisfied (and sometimes with leftovers). Daily baked goods that guarantee freshness in every bite. It’s the perfect combination of traditional bakery charm with the buzz of a modern café. Is Coniston Bakery the Best Café in Wollongong? We’ve been called the best bakery in the Illawarra — and we’re honoured by that recognition. But as our menu expands and more people choose us for their morning coffee, weekday lunch, or weekend catch-up, we have to ask: is Wollongong’s best café now on the cards? We think so. With a blend of old favourites and new offerings, Coniston Bakery is becoming more than just a stop on the way home. It’s a destination in its own right. Visit Us Today Whether you’re craving a buttery pastry, a hearty meal off the grill, or just a perfectly brewed coffee, Coniston Bakery has it all. Drop by one of our shops and experience why more people are choosing us as their go-to café in Wollongong. Fresh food, friendly service, and an atmosphere that feels like home — that’s the Coniston Bakery difference. Check Out Our Cafe Menu!  Read more
paty sausage rolls catering
Catering Wollongong NSW – Fresh, Local and Delicious with Coniston BakeryWhen it comes to hosting a special event, the food you serve sets the tone. At Coniston Bakery, we’re proud to offer premium catering Wollongong NSW services designed to take the stress out of entertaining. From family gatherings to corporate functions, our catering brings together fresh flavours, creative presentation, and the warmth of local service. Finger Food Catering in Wollongong Sometimes, it’s the small bites that leave the biggest impression. Our finger food catering Wollongong menu is ideal for cocktail parties, meetings, or celebrations where guests want to mingle freely while enjoying a variety of flavours. We prepare everything fresh, with options that range from savoury pastries and mini sandwiches to sweet treats straight from our bakery ovens. Perfect for both casual get-togethers and formal events, our finger food selection ensures everyone finds something they love. Order Your Catering Online Planning an event doesn’t have to be stressful. With Coniston Bakery, you can easily cater online – browse menus, choose your dishes, and place your order in just a few clicks. No back-and-forth phone calls or complicated processes. Our online system makes it simple to: Select from a wide range of packages. Add extra items for a customised experience. Schedule your order with confidence. Convenient Catering Delivery We know timing is everything when it comes to food. That’s why our catering delivery service ensures your order arrives fresh and ready to serve. Whether you’re hosting a morning meeting, an office lunch, or a big family event, you can rely on Coniston Bakery to deliver on time – every time. Why Choose Coniston Bakery for Catering in Wollongong? Freshly made daily using quality, local ingredients. Flexible menu options to suit small groups or large events. Professional and reliable catering delivery. Trusted local name in food and celebration for the Illawarra region. Our team is dedicated to making your event memorable, with food that delights your guests and service that makes planning simple. Book Your Catering Today If you’re searching for catering Wollongong NSW that combines flavour, convenience, and local expertise, Coniston Bakery is here to help. Explore our menus, place your catering order online, and let us take care of the rest. Our primary catering categories include:  Pies and Pastries Wraps and Rolls Fruit Platter Salad in Foil Deep Dish Quiche Croissants Slices Custom Cakes ✨ Delicious food, easy ordering, and reliable catering delivery – that’s the Coniston Bakery promise. Read more
personalised cakes at Coniston Bakery Wollongong
Celebrate Every Moment with Personalised Cakes from Coniston BakeryThere’s something special about a cake that feels like it was made just for you. At Coniston Bakery, we believe every celebration deserves a centrepiece that tells your story. That’s why our personalised cakes are more than just dessert – they’re memories baked fresh. Whether you’re planning a birthday, an anniversary, or a surprise for someone you love, our team of skilled bakers and decorators can bring your vision to life. From classic flavours to creative designs, we make sure your cake is as unique as the person you’re celebrating. Why Choose a Personalised Cake? Personalised cakes go beyond the standard off-the-shelf option. They allow you to: Match the theme of your celebration – from superheroes to floral elegance.Add a personal touch with names, messages, and custom designs.Create lasting memories by surprising someone with a cake that feels truly theirs. At Coniston Bakery, we love working closely with you to design something unforgettable – because no two celebrations are ever the same. Looking for a “Birthday Cake Shop Near Me? When the big day is coming up, the first thought is often, Where can I find the perfect birthday cake close to me?” Coniston Bakery makes that decision easy. Our local bakery is proud to be the community’s go-to birthday cake shop near me for anyone searching online. Customers love that we blend the best of tradition with creativity, offering both timeless sponge cakes and modern, eye-catching designs. Easy Cake Ordering We know planning a party can get busy, which is why we’ve made it simple to order a cake online. With just a few clicks, you can: Browse our range of flavours and fillings.Pick from our customisable designs.Place a cake order for pickup or delivery. No more last-minute stress. Your dream cake will be ready right on time – fresh, delicious, and made to impress. Why Coniston Bakery Stands Out What makes us different? Freshly baked every day using premium ingredients.Skilled decorators who can bring any idea to life.Friendly service with a local touch.Convenience for those searching “birthday cake close to me” or “birthday cake shop near me.” When you choose Coniston Bakery, you’re not just getting a cake – you’re getting craftsmanship, care, and a sprinkle of creativity. Order Your Personalised Cake Today Ready to make your celebration extra sweet? Let Coniston Bakery create the perfect personalised cake for your next event. Whether it’s a milestone birthday, a family gathering, or simply a reason to smile, we’ve got the cake to match the moment. ✨ Place your cake order today, order your cake online to get started – because every celebration deserves a cake as special as the people you love.   Read more
Minecraft edible print a custom on cake
Printed Cakes: The Sweetest Way to Make a StatementAt Coniston Bakery, we’re all about helping you celebrate in style—and nothing says “personal” quite like a printed cake. Whether it’s a birthday, graduation, anniversary, or just a cheeky inside joke between friends, a printed cake turns dessert into a moment worth remembering. What Are Printed Cakes? Printed cakes are custom cakes that feature edible images on top. Using food-safe technology, we print high-resolution photos, logos, characters, or designs directly onto a layer of icing or fondant using edible ink. The result? A completely personalised cake that looks as good as it tastes.   Why Are Edible Prints On A Cake So Cool? Printed cakes are showstoppers. They combine creativity, meaning, and flavour into one incredible centrepiece. Want your child’s favourite superhero on their cake? Easy. Need your company logo on cupcakes for a staff celebration? Done. Want to surprise your best mate with a hilarious throwback photo from 1998? You got it. Printed cakes let you tell a story—your story—right on the cake. Perfect for Every OccasionPrinted cakes are popular for all sorts of events, including: Birthdays – Kids and adults love seeing their faces or favourite characters on a cake. Weddings and anniversaries – Add a photo from your first date or wedding day. Baby showers and gender reveals – A sonogram or pastel design is always a hit. Graduations – Celebrate your graduate with their school photo or degree logo. Corporate events – Branded cakes for product launches, office parties or team wins. Retirement parties, farewells, or even apologies – Yep, we’ve printed “I’m sorry” cakes before! Why Should You Order a Printed Cake? Because it’s not just cake—it’s a conversation starter, a memory maker, and a way to connect. Printed cakes make your event more personal and meaningful. Plus, they save you from the struggle of choosing a theme. You already know what to put on it—the face, photo, or logo that matters most to you. Why Choose Coniston Bakery For Your Print On A Cake? At Coniston Bakery, we don’t just slap an image on top and call it a day. We take time to ensure your printed cake is sharp, vibrant, and perfectly matched to the flavour and style you choose. Our bakers are cake artists, and we treat every printed cake as a one-of-a-kind creation. With two locations in Coniston and Unanderra, and easy online ordering across Wollongong, it’s never been easier to bring your idea to life on cake. Looking to turn your next celebration into something unforgettable?Order your custom-printed cake from Coniston Bakery today. Shop Some of Our Inspiration Printed Cakes Now! Read more
View all